Summary - Reader Response Draft #2


In the article, “Boy Genius Boyan Slat's Giant Ocean Cleanup Machine Is Real,” Schiller (2017) explores the potential of Boyan Slat’s recent innovation, with claims to radically improve the situation in the Pacific Garbage Patch, projecting to remove 50% of the plastic waste within the next 5 years. The article mentions that Slat’s design functions as an "artificial coastline", utilizing currents to entrap and gather waste for convenient disposal. With the prototype for the former design failing in the harsh ocean conditions, Slat was able to learn from and improve his device. The new design replaces the use of foundations with anchors situated in the deep-sea layer to slow down the boom and facilitate entrapment. According to Schiller, Slat made 2 claims. Slat’s first claim was that the revised system will be more robust, affordable, and "scalable" with plans to increase the quantity of deployed booms by reducing their size. In a bid to substantiate his colossal projections for trash removal, Slat also claims to have done extensive simulations on the interaction of marine devices and trash in its natural environment. Ultimately, he plans to recycle all the plastic collected in the Patch.


While I agree on the dire need of cleaning up the ocean, Slat’s innovation fails to collect nano-plastics which greatly impact the environment, marine organisms as well as humans.


Firstly, nano-plastic impact the marine organisms in the ocean. Nano-plastic particles come in different shapes and compositions. Due to its small size, nano-plastics get stuck in the guts of marine organisms and penetrates animal tissues and organs. It is not surprising when marine organisms mistake nano-plastic for food. According to Othman (2018), a study by a scientist from the National University of Singapore (NUS) proof that nano-plastic are small enough to enter the bloodstreams and infiltrate walls of marine organisms. In addition, plastic is capable of absorbing pollutants and chemicals from the oceans. Marine organism plays a major role in the food chain as what they consume will travel up the food chain and eventually to humans.


Secondly, nano-plastics is harming the environment. Phytoplankton is greatly affected by the presence of nano-plastic as it takes up food space in their body and may potentially hinder its growth. As phytoplankton is responsible for half of the photosynthetic activity on earth, it plays a major role in the local and global ecosystems. Phytoplankton uses photosynthesis to convert carbon dioxide into oxygen. Without phytoplankton, carbon-dioxide levels would rise due to the production in both biological and industrial sources.


Lastly, the presence of nano-plastics in the ocean disrupts access to good water quality. Ocean becomes the main source of living for developing countries. The lack of a supply of clean water for drinking and sanitation leads to an increase in environmental and health issues.  According to the United Nations World Health Organization (2002), an estimated 1.7 million death a year caused by waterborne diseases such as diarrhea disease. Due to the lack of resources and funds in developing countries, water treatment is not readily available to convert ocean water into clean water.  Plastics, in general, contain toxins that are harmful to the human body in the long run. As nano-plastics cannot be seen by the naked eye, it is impossible to avoid drinking its toxins without the aid of water treatment in developing countries.


Although the message on the importance of cleaning the ocean was conveyed, it fails to focus on all types of plastics. Slat’s machine requires improvement to effectively remove all plastic waste in the Pacific Patch.



Reference List

Best, S. (2017). Shocking extent of plastic pollution: Microscopic photos show how plankton consume tiny toxic microfibres that could devastate the ecosystem. Mailonline. Retrieved, February 2 from https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-4420992/Shocking-photos-reveal-plankton-consuming-microplastics.html

Macklin, M. (2016). Plastic Pollution is Killing Plankton. How the Loss of This Species Threatens the Oceans. One Green Planet. Retrieved, February 2 from https://www.onegreenplanet.org/environment/plankton-under-threat-tiny-life-in-major-need-of-your-help/


Othman L. (2018) Nanoplastics found to accumulate in marine organisms, risk being transferred up food chain: NUS. Channel News Asia. Retrieved February 5, 2020, from https://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/plastic-pollution-nanoplastic-microplastic-ocean-nus-research-10292766


Roscam, B. (2019). How microplastic particles are turning the ocean into plastic soup. GreenBiz. Retrieved February 5, 2020, from https://www.greenbiz.com/article/how-microplastic-particles-are-turning-oceans-plastic-soup

Schiller, B. (2011). Boy Genius Boyan Slat’s Giant Ocean Clean up Machine is Real. Fast Company. Retrieved January 30, 2020, from https://www.fastcompany.com/40419899/boy-genius-boyan-slats-giant-ocean-cleanup-machine-is-real


Share:

Post a Comment

Designed by OddThemes | Distributed by Blogger Themes